# Specific Criteria

#### Specific criteria for the members of the Thesis Advisory Committee are:

1. **Committee Chair:** The chair is a voting member of the committee chosen by the MTA co-directors in consultation with the trainee and their Thesis Advisor. This Committee Chair is typically an MTA co-director or their designee. The chair must be someone who does not directly collaborate on the student’s project, will not co-author papers or abstracts with the student, has no financial conflicts of interest with the student or project, and does not supervise the work. 
2. **Thesis Advisor:** The PhD Thesis Advisor is not a voting member of the committee and is a silent observer at the Thesis Proposal and the Thesis Dissertation. However, after committee meetings, the Thesis Advisor should discuss the feedback of the committee with the student and advise on how to act on their advice as the project evolves. 
3. **Voting members:** There are a minimum of three voting members: two voting members in addition to the chair. Voting members must be faculty of the Graduate School and the MTA to which the student belongs, have no financial conflicts of interest with the student or project, and cannot directly supervise the student’s work. None of these voting members can have financial or scientific conflicts of interest with the student. This includes that no voting members can directly supervise the student or collaborate on the student’s project.
4. **Non-voting members:** One or more non-voting members can attend the committee meetings. These might include a clinical/translational (C/T) investigator, who need not be a member of the Graduate Faculty, to provide feedback about C/T impact of the research (encouraged for MD/PhD students) or others with particular expertise of value to the trainee, including collaborators. Individuals other than the Thesis Advisor who are directly involved in supervising the work (e.g., a computational mentor or co-advisor) can also attend committee meetings. In addition, experts who are not members of the training faculty of the GSBS may be invited to attend ad hoc to extend their expertise in one or more meetings. 

{% hint style="success" %}
This Advisory Committee should meet at least once per semester. In some cases, the student may be required by the Graduate School to meet with his/her/their Advisory Committee more often. To help ensure that the meeting is efficient and productive for everyone, students are encouraged to provide a project summary of progress (bullet-point style is generally sufficient) prior to each meeting. To facilitate regular check-ins, it is also suggested that students combine Advisory Committee meetings with a WIP or other formal presentation of their work.
{% endhint %}


---

# Agent Instructions: Querying This Documentation

If you need additional information that is not directly available in this page, you can query the documentation dynamically by asking a question.

Perform an HTTP GET request on the current page URL with the `ask` query parameter:

```
GET https://ismms-gs.gitbook.io/graduate-student-handbook/chapter-1-1/phd-in-biomedical-sciences-and-neuroscience/advising/thesis-advisory-committee/specific-criteria.md?ask=<question>
```

The question should be specific, self-contained, and written in natural language.
The response will contain a direct answer to the question and relevant excerpts and sources from the documentation.

Use this mechanism when the answer is not explicitly present in the current page, you need clarification or additional context, or you want to retrieve related documentation sections.